Two culturally responsive scales, Culturally Responsive Teaching Self-Efficacy Scale (CRTSE), and the Culturally Responsive Teaching Outcome Expectancy (CRTOE) Scale, written by author—were developed and administered to a sample of preservice teachers in the Midwest. Findings suggest preservice teachers are more efficacious in their ability to help students feel like important members of the classroom and develop positive, personal relationships with their students, than they are in their ability to communicate with English Language Learners. The preservice teachers were the lowest in letting their student maintain their native tongue to keep their cultural identity.