This study aimed to investigate student teachers’ beliefs, understanding, and challenge of elementary classroom management strategies. The results revealed that three of the four participants did not develop a strong teacher identity because there were barriers to that development. These participants did not challenge school-based educator (SBE) management practices even when they disagreed with their SBE. However, one participant had a strong teacher identity and navigated trying new strategies. This participant who enacted positive practices benefited from a strong orientation toward serving all pupils.