In this article, the authors present a study that investigated intercultural teaching through teachers’ collaborative conversations about critical intercultural incidents in schools. The research was conducted in Canada. The data were generated through Web-CT and face-to-face dialogues between preservice, inservice, and university teachers. Findings focus on teachers’ intercultural decision making and were organized into two subgroups: (a) decisions that tend to involve reflecting (minding) and (b) decisions that involve responding processes.